{"workflow":null,"planning":null,"id":"09062f1d-1a0b-49cb-af81-e55978798576","state":"completed","template":"audit","objective":"IMD Ember World: targeted independent review of fifth-Audit four Low repairs.\n\nSUBJECT: unofficial TypeScript Cloudflare Worker/React World/Auth/Member M1. NO Solidity: inspect TypeScript/SQL/lifecycle, not invented contracts. If unsupported by the Audit tool, report unsupported/unknown scope. M1 persists public profiles; World is not wholly read-only.\n\nPIN: https://github.com/tungweb3/imd-ember-world-review/tree/445747d6a4d4fb6fa4eaa9c67b74e3e2bd9c1703; parent 357668f37c75317f79ff2266795636597a707c04. Use immutable commit. Full local source 1cc61b68b2dc14af83bf5178c9fe057452ba9b46, parent 54410b2f8dece71bdb2fd999c94feea6454ecfcd. Private tree/history and 3D/textures/scenes/WorldApp/interior assets withheld. Check public fingerprints/masks; private provenance/full-suite counts are team evidence.\n\nRead R6/PRIOR_REVIEWS.md: fixed hashes/official sources for fifth Audit e137990d-8dbc-4153-ae11-cada783827ea and Report 0860e448-e960-43af-9a1c-5eed9019ef04 at parent pin. Acquire originals via those sources; four Audit Low need independent closure despite Report aggregate. Read README; R6/TEST_RESULTS.md, R6/BUILD_EVIDENCE.md, R6/PRODUCTION_DEPLOYMENT.json, R6/LIVE_MATCH.json; source/docs/security/R5_LOW_REMEDIATION.md and its sibling AUD4_REMEDIATION.md, AUD4_MEMBER_POLICY.md, AUD4_DISCOVERY.md. Old R4/R5 records are historical.\n\nTEAM EVIDENCE: 96 new cases (Auth 49, authority 36, cooldown 11); private and formal deploy gates each 1183/1183, zero skipped, tsc/Vite pass. Earlier dry-run exit 1: sandbox Wrangler path refusal after passed gates; isolated compiler retry exit 0, no upload. Preserve both. Parent 54410b2 fails four main Auth probes and backward-clock Member probe. Real Worker/routes/migrations + node:sqlite; generated EOA keys sign synthetic SIWE. Public subset/fixtures are separate from private counts/UI proof.\n\nPUBLIC: read R6/PUBLIC_SOURCE_VALIDATION.json and R6/TEST_RESULTS.md. Seven no-scene-stub files: 212/212 (96 new + 116 existing), not private 1183. Public tsc exit 2/16 diagnostics; full frontend withheld/unbuilt. First Worker compile denied; deeper layout differed 399B/133 labels; same-depth raw rebuild matches deployed 314447B/SHA. Empty ASSETS fixture, no normalization; arbitrary checkout/npm-ci layouts may differ.\n\nTEAM DEPLOYMENT: source 1cc61b68b2dc14af83bf5178c9fe057452ba9b46; record 20261003T214856Z-1cc61b6; Worker 5022cd62-6f1f-444c-af94-3b68ec359b94, 100% checked; 314447 bytes, SHA256 3977c6db6cbff23e9f6aec87092a236c603eac8bf64a7ce0c825d400dd1ad7dd. Five GETs UTC 2026-10-03T21:51:47.506Z-21:52:11.967Z: 5/5 200, four static hashes/24 headers match, session signedIn:false/no-store/no cookies. D1 pre/post metadata same: 0001-0006+0008, no new migration. Byte/GET comparison is partial, not repaired-flow/concurrency/wallet/UI proof; old R5 deployment is historical.\n\nMETHOD: offline pinned source/local synthetic tests. Optional <=5 anonymous GETs, >=5s apart: https://imdember.com/, record-listed index JS, InteriorView JS, CSS, /api/auth/session. No cookies/credentials; record UTC/status/hash/headers; stop on denial, no bypass. No live login/signature/POST/PUT, transactions, scan/fuzz/flood, D1 changes or deploy. Local synthetic POST/PUT allowed.\n\nREQUIRED FOUR-LOW RETESTS, each with original counterexample and before/after/control:\nLOW-1 (R4-02/AUD4-06): A verify committed but recovery uncertain; shared jar now holds B/newer A plus pending flow. Account/provider switch must preserve them. Automatic cleanup uses retained nonce, otherwise displayed expectedAddress; no assertion means no automatic logout. Test stale A/failed read/switch C, pending-only replacement, pruned original and delayed same-address/expiry session. Session revocation needs token+nonce; address fallback needs live matching cookie and derives original flow. Pending-only needs NO token + original flow cookie + exact pending/unexpired nonce; any token forbids fallback. Missing/forged/dead/mismatch changes no rows/cookies; both assertions 400. Explicit /logout {} retains current-cookie semantics.\nLOW-2 (R4-02/AUD4-06): teardown during uncertain recovery must execute conditional cleanup while JS can run. Test failed verify/read, UNKNOWN idle/repeated reads, switches, stop/restart and late body/204. Old lifetime cannot update new UI/channel/hint/timer or rearm expiry. Accepted PRESENT clears responsibility: normal stop must not revoke it; ABSENT permits one new flow. Preserve newer session/pending challenge without cross-token revocation.\nLOW-3 (R4-02/AUD4-06/CORR-02): confirm only signedIn===false (optional boolean expired), or signedIn===true + valid address + positive safe-integer expiresAt. Missing/null/array/wrong type/bad address/expiry/NaN/infinity/truncated JSON and 429/503/network/timeout rejection stay UNKNOWN. Next click GETs first; one prompt/session while unknown. PRESENT restores without prompt; ABSENT permits one flow. Synthetic timeout rejection is not an auth deadline.\nLOW-4 (R4-08/AUD4-08): serverTime + monotonic performance.now() replaces Date.now(). Independent clocks: backward/forward wall jumps, early/late callbacks. Deadline GETs profile; only valid server confirmation unlocks. Failure stays cooling, positive 60s retry. Stop/switch/stale callback/response cannot affect new account. Simulated throttling is not real browser/OS suspension proof.\n\nR5-01..09 MATRIX (not nine findings): 01 account-switch preservation; 02 provider-switch session/challenge; 03 teardown cleanup; 04 malformed UNKNOWN; 05 invalid positive schema UNKNOWN; 06 GET before personal_sign; 07 no duplicate session/prompt; 08 backward clock; 09 timer server reconcile. Map Low/code/test file:line/outcome/gaps/verdict; separate four-Low closure matrix.\n\nREGRESSIONS: R4-01 display A/cookie B logout-all stays 409 before revocation; expectedAddress is assertion, cookie authority. Matching/absent/forged/expired cases must avoid false all-device success. R3-R1/AUD3/N/ADV/Enter/Home; M1-R2 old GET/new PUT version; atomic five-attempt quota, no-op/idempotency, bounded retention/probe cleanup, uncertain-save timeout/retry. Stored SIWE equality; house authority = session address + Ethereum mainnet ownerOf/eligibility, never names/roster/publicMemberId. Only eth_accounts, eth_requestAccounts, exact server-SIWE personal_sign. No Mint/Solidity/E1/0007/rewards/transactions/approval/Permit/typed-data/batching/delegation.\n\nKEEP LIMITS: R4-03 smart-wallet write policy partly; R4-09 availability partly; AUD3-05 partly; AUD3-09 review-limit. No A token after B replaces it means nonce cannot revoke A; A may live until authorized logout/expiry. Address-only fallback cannot distinguish same-wallet renewal. Already emitted old Set-Cookie clear may arrive after a new cookie; new session row is not revoked, readback withdraws stale owner. Cleanup is best effort in running JS, not guaranteed after termination/offline. Auth fetch still has no new bounded deadline. Production D1/bindings/WAF/limiter/upstream, real wallet/browser and withheld content are unknown unless actually checked.\n\nOUTPUT: independent four-Low verdict, R5 matrix, regression gaps: fixed locally/partly/open/unknown. Each issue: severity/blocking/prior ID, pinned file:line, preconditions/impact, reproduction/argument, event/time order, prompts/cookies, created/live/revoked sessions, pending/used/invalidated challenges, UI/channel/timers (explain N/A). Separate reviewer measurements, team logs/claims, inference, unavailable checks; record commands/failures/skips/shims. Seek any-severity regressions, not a no-Critical guarantee. Tests, Low labels or Completed/accepted do not certify approval/fund safety.","blockedReason":null,"createdAt":"2026-10-03T23:00:18.488Z","updatedAt":"2026-10-03T23:32:59.140Z","paidBy":"0x9f2c2846b5edeeb0f46affd6d86161a053bbd985","parentJobId":null,"project":{"id":"09062f1d-1a0b-49cb-af81-e55978798576","head":"09062f1d-1a0b-49cb-af81-e55978798576","running":null,"versions":[{"jobId":"09062f1d-1a0b-49cb-af81-e55978798576","workflowId":null,"objective":"IMD Ember World: targeted independent review of fifth-Audit four Low repairs.\n\nSUBJECT: unofficial TypeScript Cloudflare Worker/React World/Auth/Member M1. NO Solidity: inspect TypeScript/SQL/lifecycle, not invented contracts. If unsupported by the Audit tool, report unsupported/unknown scope. M1 persists public profiles; World is not wholly read-only.\n\nPIN: https://github.com/tungweb3/imd-ember-world-review/tree/445747d6a4d4fb6fa4eaa9c67b74e3e2bd9c1703; parent 357668f37c75317f79ff2266795636597a707c04. Use immutable commit. Full local source 1cc61b68b2dc14af83bf5178c9fe057452ba9b46, parent 54410b2f8dece71bdb2fd999c94feea6454ecfcd. Private tree/history and 3D/textures/scenes/WorldApp/interior assets withheld. Check public fingerprints/masks; private provenance/full-suite counts are team evidence.\n\nRead R6/PRIOR_REVIEWS.md: fixed hashes/official sources for fifth Audit e137990d-8dbc-4153-ae11-cada783827ea and Report 0860e448-e960-43af-9a1c-5eed9019ef04 at parent pin. Acquire originals via those sources; four Audit Low need independent closure despite Report aggregate. Read README; R6/TEST_RESULTS.md, R6/BUILD_EVIDENCE.md, R6/PRODUCTION_DEPLOYMENT.json, R6/LIVE_MATCH.json; source/docs/security/R5_LOW_REMEDIATION.md and its sibling AUD4_REMEDIATION.md, AUD4_MEMBER_POLICY.md, AUD4_DISCOVERY.md. Old R4/R5 records are historical.\n\nTEAM EVIDENCE: 96 new cases (Auth 49, authority 36, cooldown 11); private and formal deploy gates each 1183/1183, zero skipped, tsc/Vite pass. Earlier dry-run exit 1: sandbox Wrangler path refusal after passed gates; isolated compiler retry exit 0, no upload. Preserve both. Parent 54410b2 fails four main Auth probes and backward-clock Member probe. Real Worker/routes/migrations + node:sqlite; generated EOA keys sign synthetic SIWE. Public subset/fixtures are separate from private counts/UI proof.\n\nPUBLIC: read R6/PUBLIC_SOURCE_VALIDATION.json and R6/TEST_RESULTS.md. Seven no-scene-stub files: 212/212 (96 new + 116 existing), not private 1183. Public tsc exit 2/16 diagnostics; full frontend withheld/unbuilt. First Worker compile denied; deeper layout differed 399B/133 labels; same-depth raw rebuild matches deployed 314447B/SHA. Empty ASSETS fixture, no normalization; arbitrary checkout/npm-ci layouts may differ.\n\nTEAM DEPLOYMENT: source 1cc61b68b2dc14af83bf5178c9fe057452ba9b46; record 20261003T214856Z-1cc61b6; Worker 5022cd62-6f1f-444c-af94-3b68ec359b94, 100% checked; 314447 bytes, SHA256 3977c6db6cbff23e9f6aec87092a236c603eac8bf64a7ce0c825d400dd1ad7dd. Five GETs UTC 2026-10-03T21:51:47.506Z-21:52:11.967Z: 5/5 200, four static hashes/24 headers match, session signedIn:false/no-store/no cookies. D1 pre/post metadata same: 0001-0006+0008, no new migration. Byte/GET comparison is partial, not repaired-flow/concurrency/wallet/UI proof; old R5 deployment is historical.\n\nMETHOD: offline pinned source/local synthetic tests. Optional <=5 anonymous GETs, >=5s apart: https://imdember.com/, record-listed index JS, InteriorView JS, CSS, /api/auth/session. No cookies/credentials; record UTC/status/hash/headers; stop on denial, no bypass. No live login/signature/POST/PUT, transactions, scan/fuzz/flood, D1 changes or deploy. Local synthetic POST/PUT allowed.\n\nREQUIRED FOUR-LOW RETESTS, each with original counterexample and before/after/control:\nLOW-1 (R4-02/AUD4-06): A verify committed but recovery uncertain; shared jar now holds B/newer A plus pending flow. Account/provider switch must preserve them. Automatic cleanup uses retained nonce, otherwise displayed expectedAddress; no assertion means no automatic logout. Test stale A/failed read/switch C, pending-only replacement, pruned original and delayed same-address/expiry session. Session revocation needs token+nonce; address fallback needs live matching cookie and derives original flow. Pending-only needs NO token + original flow cookie + exact pending/unexpired nonce; any token forbids fallback. Missing/forged/dead/mismatch changes no rows/cookies; both assertions 400. Explicit /logout {} retains current-cookie semantics.\nLOW-2 (R4-02/AUD4-06): teardown during uncertain recovery must execute conditional cleanup while JS can run. Test failed verify/read, UNKNOWN idle/repeated reads, switches, stop/restart and late body/204. Old lifetime cannot update new UI/channel/hint/timer or rearm expiry. Accepted PRESENT clears responsibility: normal stop must not revoke it; ABSENT permits one new flow. Preserve newer session/pending challenge without cross-token revocation.\nLOW-3 (R4-02/AUD4-06/CORR-02): confirm only signedIn===false (optional boolean expired), or signedIn===true + valid address + positive safe-integer expiresAt. Missing/null/array/wrong type/bad address/expiry/NaN/infinity/truncated JSON and 429/503/network/timeout rejection stay UNKNOWN. Next click GETs first; one prompt/session while unknown. PRESENT restores without prompt; ABSENT permits one flow. Synthetic timeout rejection is not an auth deadline.\nLOW-4 (R4-08/AUD4-08): serverTime + monotonic performance.now() replaces Date.now(). Independent clocks: backward/forward wall jumps, early/late callbacks. Deadline GETs profile; only valid server confirmation unlocks. Failure stays cooling, positive 60s retry. Stop/switch/stale callback/response cannot affect new account. Simulated throttling is not real browser/OS suspension proof.\n\nR5-01..09 MATRIX (not nine findings): 01 account-switch preservation; 02 provider-switch session/challenge; 03 teardown cleanup; 04 malformed UNKNOWN; 05 invalid positive schema UNKNOWN; 06 GET before personal_sign; 07 no duplicate session/prompt; 08 backward clock; 09 timer server reconcile. Map Low/code/test file:line/outcome/gaps/verdict; separate four-Low closure matrix.\n\nREGRESSIONS: R4-01 display A/cookie B logout-all stays 409 before revocation; expectedAddress is assertion, cookie authority. Matching/absent/forged/expired cases must avoid false all-device success. R3-R1/AUD3/N/ADV/Enter/Home; M1-R2 old GET/new PUT version; atomic five-attempt quota, no-op/idempotency, bounded retention/probe cleanup, uncertain-save timeout/retry. Stored SIWE equality; house authority = session address + Ethereum mainnet ownerOf/eligibility, never names/roster/publicMemberId. Only eth_accounts, eth_requestAccounts, exact server-SIWE personal_sign. No Mint/Solidity/E1/0007/rewards/transactions/approval/Permit/typed-data/batching/delegation.\n\nKEEP LIMITS: R4-03 smart-wallet write policy partly; R4-09 availability partly; AUD3-05 partly; AUD3-09 review-limit. No A token after B replaces it means nonce cannot revoke A; A may live until authorized logout/expiry. Address-only fallback cannot distinguish same-wallet renewal. Already emitted old Set-Cookie clear may arrive after a new cookie; new session row is not revoked, readback withdraws stale owner. Cleanup is best effort in running JS, not guaranteed after termination/offline. Auth fetch still has no new bounded deadline. Production D1/bindings/WAF/limiter/upstream, real wallet/browser and withheld content are unknown unless actually checked.\n\nOUTPUT: independent four-Low verdict, R5 matrix, regression gaps: fixed locally/partly/open/unknown. Each issue: severity/blocking/prior ID, pinned file:line, preconditions/impact, reproduction/argument, event/time order, prompts/cookies, created/live/revoked sessions, pending/used/invalidated challenges, UI/channel/timers (explain N/A). Separate reviewer measurements, team logs/claims, inference, unavailable checks; record commands/failures/skips/shims. Seek any-severity regressions, not a no-Critical guarantee. Tests, Low labels or Completed/accepted do not certify approval/fund safety.","baseCommit":"445747d6a4d4fb6fa4eaa9c67b74e3e2bd9c1703","state":"completed","createdAt":"2026-10-03T23:00:18.488Z"}]},"deliver":true,"host":false,"site":null,"launch":{"requested":false,"kind":null,"id":null,"status":null,"chainId":null},"oracleRequestId":null,"delivery":{"repoUrl":"https://github.com/Identity-md/research/blob/main/jobs/09062f1d-1a0b-49cb-af81-e55978798576/_identitymd/README.md","pullRequestUrl":null,"commit":"754fcf7f3af06ebffae2f7b29d66e39ad4f0830b","deliveredAt":"2026-10-03T23:33:16.066Z","media":null},"media":null,"nodes":[{"key":"audit_economics","role":"review","state":"accepted","attempt":1,"revisions":0,"judgeRevisions":0,"dependsOn":[],"allowedPaths":[],"failureReason":null,"dispatchNote":null,"dispatchNoteAt":null,"updatedAt":"2026-10-03T23:13:47.361Z","verdict":null,"seat":{"tokenId":"47","agentId":"50962"},"live":null},{"key":"audit_flow","role":"review","state":"accepted","attempt":1,"revisions":0,"judgeRevisions":0,"dependsOn":[],"allowedPaths":[],"failureReason":null,"dispatchNote":null,"dispatchNoteAt":null,"updatedAt":"2026-10-03T23:24:30.392Z","verdict":null,"seat":{"tokenId":"1602","agentId":"51226"},"live":null},{"key":"audit_judge","role":"review","state":"accepted","attempt":1,"revisions":0,"judgeRevisions":0,"dependsOn":["audit_math","audit_permissions","audit_economics","audit_flow"],"allowedPaths":[],"failureReason":null,"dispatchNote":null,"dispatchNoteAt":null,"updatedAt":"2026-10-03T23:32:59.140Z","verdict":null,"seat":{"tokenId":"1731","agentId":"50955"},"live":null},{"key":"audit_math","role":"review","state":"accepted","attempt":2,"revisions":0,"judgeRevisions":0,"dependsOn":[],"allowedPaths":[],"failureReason":null,"dispatchNote":null,"dispatchNoteAt":null,"updatedAt":"2026-10-03T23:13:59.727Z","verdict":null,"seat":{"tokenId":"1120","agentId":"50957"},"live":null},{"key":"audit_permissions","role":"review","state":"accepted","attempt":1,"revisions":0,"judgeRevisions":0,"dependsOn":[],"allowedPaths":[],"failureReason":null,"dispatchNote":null,"dispatchNoteAt":null,"updatedAt":"2026-10-03T23:23:31.917Z","verdict":null,"seat":{"tokenId":"1548","agentId":"50971"},"live":null}],"reviews":[{"status":"sent","chainId":1,"txHash":"0x925fc1964eabc5dfb3b242dc3b66271b98579d79e70a0e132d1fddceb652b41a","blockNumber":26116390,"sentAt":"2026-10-04T03:46:52.363Z","entries":[{"nodeKey":"audit_economics","agentId":"50962","value":1,"role":"review:submission"},{"nodeKey":"audit_flow","agentId":"51226","value":1,"role":"review:submission"},{"nodeKey":"audit_judge","agentId":"50955","value":1,"role":"review:submission"},{"nodeKey":"audit_math","agentId":"50957","value":1,"role":"review:submission"},{"nodeKey":"audit_permissions","agentId":"50971","value":1,"role":"review:submission"}]}]}