{"key": "s4-fresh-3", "idea": "Measure-only replication: B_RC4 (C) vs B_RC (K) on fresh seeds 931000..931499; only spread 4 may differ.", "candidate_sha256": "27cef4140f19ecf15aeaa82c8a4bc70f9f066083a5bed10bcb963d8ecbb9b8aa", "comparator_sha256": "02696ea6fd0922f64167a1153748f6a38bf2fd5d87c7a4ac6cb974bb9482f57c", "seeds": {"start": 931000, "end": 931499}, "n": 500, "complete": true, "missing_seeds": [], "failures": [], "check_values": {"seeds": [310000, 310003], "K_total_edge": [17.512655, 24.258579, 2.390311, 249.541133], "expected_B_RC": [17.512655, 24.258579, 2.390311, 249.541133], "match": true}, "python_version": "3.12.3", "seconds_per_simulation": {"candidate": 0.21224567031115293, "comparator": 0.2128991011772305, "by_spread": {"1": {"candidate": 0.1833694074164938, "comparator": 0.18340189979860075}, "2": {"candidate": 0.21440418958497634, "comparator": 0.21401017742131703}, "3": {"candidate": 0.2217515678895825, "comparator": 0.2216304266652049}, "4": {"candidate": 0.23184470696029283, "comparator": 0.23492604197423544}}}, "overall": {"n": 500, "sum_d": 83.32036351620009, "sum_d2": 919.934656837799, "mean_diff": 0.16664072703240018, "se": 0.06026162369302425, "comparator_mean": 103.218327647264, "retail_diff": 0.03301031893940014, "arb_diff": 0.13363040810000001}, "by_spread": {"1": {"n": 135, "sum_d": 0.0, "sum_d2": 0.0, "mean_diff": 0.0, "se": 0.0, "comparator_mean": 41.750004600026664, "retail_diff": 0.0, "arb_diff": 0.0}, "2": {"n": 112, "sum_d": 0.0, "sum_d2": 0.0, "mean_diff": 0.0, "se": 0.0, "comparator_mean": 88.2885547078384, "retail_diff": 0.0, "arb_diff": 0.0}, "3": {"n": 129, "sum_d": 0.0, "sum_d2": 0.0, "mean_diff": 0.0, "se": 0.0, "comparator_mean": 131.478932497593, "retail_diff": 0.0, "arb_diff": 0.0}, "4": {"n": 124, "sum_d": 83.32036351620009, "sum_d2": 919.934656837799, "mean_diff": 0.6719384154532265, "se": 0.238001958104304, "comparator_mean": 154.22429663839517, "retail_diff": 0.1331061247556457, "arb_diff": 0.5388322907258065}}, "per_seed": [[931000, 4, 4.115585], [931001, 2, 0.0], [931002, 1, 0.0], [931003, 1, 0.0], [931004, 3, 0.0], [931005, 1, 0.0], [931006, 4, 0.205971], [931007, 1, 0.0], [931008, 2, 0.0], [931009, 2, 0.0], [931010, 2, 0.0], [931011, 3, 0.0], [931012, 1, 0.0], [931013, 1, 0.0], [931014, 1, 0.0], [931015, 2, 0.0], [931016, 1, 0.0], [931017, 1, 0.0], [931018, 4, 0.784706], [931019, 4, 7.127704], [931020, 2, 0.0], [931021, 1, 0.0], [931022, 4, -15.456484], [931023, 2, 0.0], [931024, 1, 0.0], [931025, 1, 0.0], [931026, 1, 0.0], [931027, 3, 0.0], [931028, 2, 0.0], [931029, 1, 0.0], [931030, 3, 0.0], [931031, 4, 3.451088], [931032, 4, 0.195129], [931033, 4, 0.064391], [931034, 2, 0.0], [931035, 2, 0.0], [931036, 1, 0.0], [931037, 1, 0.0], [931038, 4, -0.657349], [931039, 1, 0.0], [931040, 2, 0.0], [931041, 2, 0.0], [931042, 3, 0.0], [931043, 1, 0.0], [931044, 1, 0.0], [931045, 1, 0.0], [931046, 4, 0.032139], [931047, 4, -4.535082], [931048, 3, 0.0], [931049, 3, 0.0], [931050, 1, 0.0], [931051, 4, 0.885685], [931052, 4, 3.412473], [931053, 2, 0.0], [931054, 1, 0.0], [931055, 4, 3.724458], [931056, 3, 0.0], [931057, 4, 0.577548], [931058, 1, 0.0], [931059, 2, 0.0], [931060, 4, 1.110271], [931061, 2, 0.0], [931062, 4, 0.20907], [931063, 4, 1.69918], [931064, 4, 0.968851], [931065, 3, 0.0], [931066, 2, 0.0], [931067, 3, 0.0], [931068, 1, 0.0], [931069, 3, 0.0], [931070, 2, 0.0], [931071, 2, 0.0], [931072, 2, 0.0], [931073, 2, 0.0], [931074, 3, 0.0], [931075, 2, 0.0], [931076, 3, 0.0], [931077, 4, 0.093786], [931078, 3, 0.0], [931079, 3, 0.0], [931080, 1, 0.0], [931081, 1, 0.0], [931082, 1, 0.0], [931083, 1, 0.0], [931084, 4, 0.364303], [931085, 1, 0.0], [931086, 4, 1.002778], [931087, 3, 0.0], [931088, 3, 0.0], [931089, 3, 0.0], [931090, 3, 0.0], [931091, 2, 0.0], [931092, 1, 0.0], [931093, 4, 2.881199], [931094, 3, 0.0], [931095, 2, 0.0], [931096, 1, 0.0], [931097, 4, -0.081584], [931098, 3, 0.0], [931099, 3, 0.0], [931100, 1, 0.0], [931101, 2, 0.0], [931102, 1, 0.0], [931103, 3, 0.0], [931104, 3, 0.0], [931105, 2, 0.0], [931106, 2, 0.0], [931107, 4, 2.661671], [931108, 4, 0.284811], [931109, 4, 0.314553], [931110, 2, 0.0], [931111, 4, 0.280693], [931112, 4, 0.197484], [931113, 2, 0.0], [931114, 2, 0.0], [931115, 4, 2.992284], [931116, 4, -2.327275], [931117, 2, 0.0], [931118, 2, 0.0], [931119, 3, 0.0], [931120, 1, 0.0], [931121, 3, 0.0], [931122, 3, 0.0], [931123, 2, 0.0], [931124, 4, 0.119319], [931125, 1, 0.0], [931126, 1, 0.0], [931127, 3, 0.0], [931128, 2, 0.0], [931129, 1, 0.0], [931130, 4, 0.736717], [931131, 4, 1.123543], [931132, 2, 0.0], [931133, 4, 0.101359], [931134, 1, 0.0], [931135, 2, 0.0], [931136, 2, 0.0], [931137, 1, 0.0], [931138, 4, 1.680288], [931139, 4, -0.11239], [931140, 1, 0.0], [931141, 4, 0.068232], [931142, 4, -0.299281], [931143, 2, 0.0], [931144, 4, 0.041399], [931145, 1, 0.0], [931146, 2, 0.0], [931147, 1, 0.0], [931148, 2, 0.0], [931149, 3, 0.0], [931150, 3, 0.0], [931151, 1, 0.0], [931152, 2, 0.0], [931153, 1, 0.0], [931154, 1, 0.0], [931155, 3, 0.0], [931156, 3, 0.0], [931157, 4, 1.240757], [931158, 4, 0.079999], [931159, 4, 0.108128], [931160, 4, 1.887448], [931161, 3, 0.0], [931162, 2, 0.0], [931163, 1, 0.0], [931164, 4, 1.765687], [931165, 2, 0.0], [931166, 1, 0.0], [931167, 1, 0.0], [931168, 3, 0.0], [931169, 3, 0.0], [931170, 2, 0.0], [931171, 1, 0.0], [931172, 1, 0.0], [931173, 4, 0.365602], [931174, 2, 0.0], [931175, 2, 0.0], [931176, 3, 0.0], [931177, 3, 0.0], [931178, 3, 0.0], [931179, 2, 0.0], [931180, 1, 0.0], [931181, 2, 0.0], [931182, 1, 0.0], [931183, 4, 2.567661], [931184, 1, 0.0], [931185, 2, 0.0], [931186, 3, 0.0], [931187, 3, 0.0], [931188, 2, 0.0], [931189, 4, 0.133762], [931190, 1, 0.0], [931191, 4, -0.815567], [931192, 2, 0.0], [931193, 3, 0.0], [931194, 1, 0.0], [931195, 2, 0.0], [931196, 1, 0.0], [931197, 1, 0.0], [931198, 2, 0.0], [931199, 2, 0.0], [931200, 3, 0.0], [931201, 3, 0.0], [931202, 2, 0.0], [931203, 4, 0.929797], [931204, 4, 1.397446], [931205, 3, 0.0], [931206, 4, 0.193526], [931207, 4, 0.141416], [931208, 2, 0.0], [931209, 2, 0.0], [931210, 3, 0.0], [931211, 1, 0.0], [931212, 2, 0.0], [931213, 3, 0.0], [931214, 2, 0.0], [931215, 4, 0.046915], [931216, 3, 0.0], [931217, 4, 2.356284], [931218, 3, 0.0], [931219, 2, 0.0], [931220, 3, 0.0], [931221, 1, 0.0], [931222, 3, 0.0], [931223, 1, 0.0], [931224, 4, -0.122058], [931225, 4, -0.556682], [931226, 4, 1.041565], [931227, 4, 1.139006], [931228, 3, 0.0], [931229, 4, -1.270804], [931230, 3, 0.0], [931231, 4, -0.474011], [931232, 2, 0.0], [931233, 2, 0.0], [931234, 1, 0.0], [931235, 3, 0.0], [931236, 4, -0.107155], [931237, 4, 0.691806], [931238, 1, 0.0], [931239, 4, -2.092867], [931240, 3, 0.0], [931241, 4, -0.57283], [931242, 3, 0.0], [931243, 4, 0.615948], [931244, 1, 0.0], [931245, 1, 0.0], [931246, 1, 0.0], [931247, 1, 0.0], [931248, 1, 0.0], [931249, 4, -0.518337], [931250, 1, 0.0], [931251, 1, 0.0], [931252, 3, 0.0], [931253, 1, 0.0], [931254, 4, 3.627617], [931255, 3, 0.0], [931256, 1, 0.0], [931257, 3, 0.0], [931258, 4, -0.03894], [931259, 1, 0.0], [931260, 3, 0.0], [931261, 4, 1.413407], [931262, 3, 0.0], [931263, 3, 0.0], [931264, 3, 0.0], [931265, 1, 0.0], [931266, 1, 0.0], [931267, 4, 0.379604], [931268, 1, 0.0], [931269, 1, 0.0], [931270, 3, 0.0], [931271, 4, 0.086194], [931272, 3, 0.0], [931273, 3, 0.0], [931274, 2, 0.0], [931275, 4, -1.154706], [931276, 2, 0.0], [931277, 2, 0.0], [931278, 4, -0.149817], [931279, 1, 0.0], [931280, 1, 0.0], [931281, 2, 0.0], [931282, 2, 0.0], [931283, 2, 0.0], [931284, 2, 0.0], [931285, 1, 0.0], [931286, 1, 0.0], [931287, 4, 0.031525], [931288, 2, 0.0], [931289, 2, 0.0], [931290, 1, 0.0], [931291, 1, 0.0], [931292, 2, 0.0], [931293, 3, 0.0], [931294, 1, 0.0], [931295, 4, 1.898323], [931296, 1, 0.0], [931297, 4, -0.22127], [931298, 4, 0.458236], [931299, 3, 0.0], [931300, 3, 0.0], [931301, 1, 0.0], [931302, 1, 0.0], [931303, 4, 0.013755], [931304, 1, 0.0], [931305, 3, 0.0], [931306, 2, 0.0], [931307, 4, 1.179579], [931308, 4, 0.415656], [931309, 3, 0.0], [931310, 1, 0.0], [931311, 1, 0.0], [931312, 3, 0.0], [931313, 1, 0.0], [931314, 4, 0.137418], [931315, 4, -9.82507], [931316, 4, 2.721298], [931317, 2, 0.0], [931318, 4, 0.671605], [931319, 3, 0.0], [931320, 2, 0.0], [931321, 1, 0.0], [931322, 3, 0.0], [931323, 2, 0.0], [931324, 2, 0.0], [931325, 1, 0.0], [931326, 1, 0.0], [931327, 3, 0.0], [931328, 3, 0.0], [931329, 4, -2.717557], [931330, 4, 0.594541], [931331, 4, 0.054286], [931332, 2, 0.0], [931333, 4, 0.338668], [931334, 3, 0.0], [931335, 4, 0.046753], [931336, 4, 1.871392], [931337, 3, 0.0], [931338, 3, 0.0], [931339, 3, 0.0], [931340, 2, 0.0], [931341, 1, 0.0], [931342, 2, 0.0], [931343, 3, 0.0], [931344, 3, 0.0], [931345, 4, 4.833872], [931346, 3, 0.0], [931347, 3, 0.0], [931348, 3, 0.0], [931349, 3, 0.0], [931350, 1, 0.0], [931351, 3, 0.0], [931352, 4, -0.110241], [931353, 4, 1.347913], [931354, 3, 0.0], [931355, 1, 0.0], [931356, 3, 0.0], [931357, 3, 0.0], [931358, 3, 0.0], [931359, 1, 0.0], [931360, 4, 7.19877], [931361, 1, 0.0], [931362, 3, 0.0], [931363, 4, 12.02705], [931364, 4, 3.798981], [931365, 4, -0.050496], [931366, 2, 0.0], [931367, 4, 0.238896], [931368, 1, 0.0], [931369, 1, 0.0], [931370, 3, 0.0], [931371, 2, 0.0], [931372, 4, 1.726649], [931373, 1, 0.0], [931374, 4, -0.196309], [931375, 4, 2.086662], [931376, 3, 0.0], [931377, 3, 0.0], [931378, 1, 0.0], [931379, 4, 0.354201], [931380, 3, 0.0], [931381, 2, 0.0], [931382, 2, 0.0], [931383, 2, 0.0], [931384, 1, 0.0], [931385, 1, 0.0], [931386, 4, 0.118237], [931387, 2, 0.0], [931388, 2, 0.0], [931389, 1, 0.0], [931390, 1, 0.0], [931391, 1, 0.0], [931392, 3, 0.0], [931393, 1, 0.0], [931394, 4, 1.065642], [931395, 3, 0.0], [931396, 2, 0.0], [931397, 2, 0.0], [931398, 2, 0.0], [931399, 3, 0.0], [931400, 1, 0.0], [931401, 1, 0.0], [931402, 2, 0.0], [931403, 2, 0.0], [931404, 1, 0.0], [931405, 4, 7.158652], [931406, 1, 0.0], [931407, 4, 0.016083], [931408, 2, 0.0], [931409, 1, 0.0], [931410, 1, 0.0], [931411, 4, -0.967312], [931412, 3, 0.0], [931413, 2, 0.0], [931414, 4, 0.942961], [931415, 3, 0.0], [931416, 1, 0.0], [931417, 3, 0.0], [931418, 1, 0.0], [931419, 1, 0.0], [931420, 1, 0.0], [931421, 2, 0.0], [931422, 4, 0.303851], [931423, 2, 0.0], [931424, 3, 0.0], [931425, 3, 0.0], [931426, 3, 0.0], [931427, 1, 0.0], [931428, 2, 0.0], [931429, 4, 0.508017], [931430, 3, 0.0], [931431, 4, -0.739101], [931432, 3, 0.0], [931433, 3, 0.0], [931434, 3, 0.0], [931435, 2, 0.0], [931436, 3, 0.0], [931437, 1, 0.0], [931438, 4, -1.236874], [931439, 4, -0.183879], [931440, 2, 0.0], [931441, 3, 0.0], [931442, 4, 3.690862], [931443, 2, 0.0], [931444, 2, 0.0], [931445, 2, 0.0], [931446, 2, 0.0], [931447, 3, 0.0], [931448, 1, 0.0], [931449, 4, -0.386459], [931450, 3, 0.0], [931451, 4, 0.003508], [931452, 3, 0.0], [931453, 1, 0.0], [931454, 3, 0.0], [931455, 1, 0.0], [931456, 3, 0.0], [931457, 2, 0.0], [931458, 3, 0.0], [931459, 4, 0.383571], [931460, 2, 0.0], [931461, 4, 2.966557], [931462, 2, 0.0], [931463, 1, 0.0], [931464, 1, 0.0], [931465, 1, 0.0], [931466, 2, 0.0], [931467, 1, 0.0], [931468, 1, 0.0], [931469, 3, 0.0], [931470, 3, 0.0], [931471, 1, 0.0], [931472, 3, 0.0], [931473, 2, 0.0], [931474, 3, 0.0], [931475, 3, 0.0], [931476, 3, 0.0], [931477, 2, 0.0], [931478, 1, 0.0], [931479, 4, -1.696507], [931480, 2, 0.0], [931481, 2, 0.0], [931482, 1, 0.0], [931483, 1, 0.0], [931484, 3, 0.0], [931485, 2, 0.0], [931486, 1, 0.0], [931487, 4, 1.256026], [931488, 3, 0.0], [931489, 1, 0.0], [931490, 3, 0.0], [931491, 2, 0.0], [931492, 3, 0.0], [931493, 4, 1.069075], [931494, 3, 0.0], [931495, 4, 0.466142], [931496, 3, 0.0], [931497, 1, 0.0], [931498, 4, 3.281204], [931499, 3, 0.0]], "worst_seeds": [{"seed": 931022, "s": 4, "d": -15.456484, "candidate_edge": 791.061671, "comparator_edge": 806.518155}, {"seed": 931315, "s": 4, "d": -9.82507, "candidate_edge": 645.575122, "comparator_edge": 655.400191}, {"seed": 931047, "s": 4, "d": -4.535082, "candidate_edge": 414.442276, "comparator_edge": 418.977358}, {"seed": 931329, "s": 4, "d": -2.717557, "candidate_edge": 194.808935, "comparator_edge": 197.526492}, {"seed": 931116, "s": 4, "d": -2.327275, "candidate_edge": 67.905877, "comparator_edge": 70.233152}, {"seed": 931239, "s": 4, "d": -2.092867, "candidate_edge": 44.875436, "comparator_edge": 46.968303}, {"seed": 931479, "s": 4, "d": -1.696507, "candidate_edge": 1227.598873, "comparator_edge": 1229.295381}, {"seed": 931229, "s": 4, "d": -1.270804, "candidate_edge": 24.78656, "comparator_edge": 26.057365}, {"seed": 931438, "s": 4, "d": -1.236874, "candidate_edge": 21.985867, "comparator_edge": 23.222741}, {"seed": 931275, "s": 4, "d": -1.154706, "candidate_edge": 287.314829, "comparator_edge": 288.469535}], "off_target_zero": true, "notes": "All SHA-256 verified; K check values match B_RC exactly. Unmodified simulator at b244530, default config, single process, chunks of 50. Spread from first competitor quotes equals sampled spread_ticks on 500/500 seeds; no missing quotes (0). Off-target nonzero d count (s=1..3): 0. Spread 4: n=124, mean 0.6719 se 0.2380. Overall mean 0.1666 se 0.0603."}