{"key":"ma-fresh-2","idea":"Measure MA against B_RC on fresh paired seeds, overall and per initial competitor spread; spread 1 is P's difference.","candidate_sha256":"5d1bd5272884f513b19f0e66a7c235f6c188a08e4f7787ac9346f1614dda3ed3","comparator_sha256":"02696ea6fd0922f64167a1153748f6a38bf2fd5d87c7a4ac6cb974bb9482f57c","seeds":{"start":920500,"end":920999},"n":500,"complete":true,"missing_seeds":[],"failures":[],"check_values":[{"seed":310000,"comparator_edge":17.5126554022,"expected":17.512655,"matches_6dp":true},{"seed":310001,"comparator_edge":24.2585786274,"expected":24.258579,"matches_6dp":true},{"seed":310002,"comparator_edge":2.3903113616,"expected":2.390311,"matches_6dp":true},{"seed":310003,"comparator_edge":249.5411334743,"expected":249.541133,"matches_6dp":true}],"python_version":"3.12.3","seconds_per_simulation":{"candidate":0.7900517530655489,"comparator":0.7834756977451034,"overall":{"candidate":0.7900517530655489,"comparator":0.7834756977451034},"by_spread":{"1":{"candidate":0.656526925228109,"comparator":0.6595534747124675},"2":{"candidate":0.7981956678126673,"comparator":0.7888411115755194},"3":{"candidate":0.8318821681134081,"comparator":0.8244975109303223},"4":{"candidate":0.8579055966194054,"comparator":0.8464608079375466}}},"overall":{"n":500,"sum_d":98.1965491899004,"sum_d2":9673.613404782704,"mean_diff":0.19639309837980076,"se":0.19670969098140634,"comparator_mean":90.4149317658774,"retail_diff":0.4057284578834005,"arb_diff":-0.20933535946900028},"by_spread":{"1":{"n":109,"sum_d":238.6920169034,"sum_d2":8221.905787853144,"mean_diff":2.1898350174623853,"se":0.8087195579319808,"comparator_mean":46.024863498455964,"retail_diff":0.8054269159339456,"arb_diff":1.3844081015633025},"2":{"n":140,"sum_d":-65.38850892859986,"sum_d2":1053.3678360298886,"mean_diff":-0.46706077806142754,"se":0.22926077956092455,"comparator_mean":69.66047784547357,"retail_diff":0.5208922987128577,"arb_diff":-0.9879530767392862},"3":{"n":139,"sum_d":-75.10695878489975,"sum_d2":398.3397808996719,"mean_diff":-0.5403378329848902,"se":0.13656735997002828,"comparator_mean":108.11265704411439,"retail_diff":0.30322139054028857,"arb_diff":-0.8435592234633097},"4":{"n":112,"sum_d":0.0,"sum_d2":0.0,"mean_diff":0.0,"se":0.0,"comparator_mean":137.59490655454286,"retail_diff":0.0,"arb_diff":0.0}},"per_seed":[[920500,1,1.110838],[920501,4,0.0],[920502,3,-1.479304],[920503,3,0.06538],[920504,4,0.0],[920505,3,-2.882722],[920506,1,2.271691],[920507,3,-2.247013],[920508,4,0.0],[920509,2,-0.253192],[920510,3,-0.93319],[920511,3,-0.004741],[920512,1,0.168437],[920513,4,0.0],[920514,2,0.381015],[920515,1,0.790989],[920516,3,1.6863],[920517,3,-0.000647],[920518,3,-0.115623],[920519,3,-0.482038],[920520,1,3.549001],[920521,4,0.0],[920522,3,-2.294935],[920523,2,3.889496],[920524,2,-0.555854],[920525,3,-1.542387],[920526,4,0.0],[920527,2,-0.152242],[920528,3,1.340407],[920529,2,-0.537908],[920530,2,0.015655],[920531,4,0.0],[920532,4,0.0],[920533,4,0.0],[920534,3,-1.053722],[920535,3,-0.418094],[920536,2,-0.944856],[920537,2,0.098272],[920538,4,0.0],[920539,1,4.750999],[920540,4,0.0],[920541,2,-0.61951],[920542,4,0.0],[920543,1,0.157249],[920544,1,0.002681],[920545,2,-2.036935],[920546,1,37.491326],[920547,1,0.019021],[920548,2,-0.573286],[920549,2,0.049759],[920550,2,0.308022],[920551,3,-1.112114],[920552,2,0.065876],[920553,1,-0.011595],[920554,3,-1.188675],[920555,3,1.66256],[920556,2,-2.984656],[920557,2,1.333539],[920558,2,1.075046],[920559,4,0.0],[920560,3,-0.181616],[920561,3,0.007449],[920562,1,0.139527],[920563,3,0.00788],[920564,2,-0.079618],[920565,1,10.343255],[920566,2,-3.590271],[920567,2,-1.034012],[920568,3,-1.603446],[920569,3,-0.177016],[920570,3,-0.199181],[920571,4,0.0],[920572,3,-1.093239],[920573,2,0.425859],[920574,2,0.20458],[920575,3,-1.23961],[920576,4,0.0],[920577,3,0.186351],[920578,3,0.275659],[920579,3,-0.975219],[920580,4,0.0],[920581,1,0.068947],[920582,4,0.0],[920583,3,-1.713795],[920584,1,-3.430534],[920585,3,-0.287906],[920586,3,1.87837],[920587,3,0.101706],[920588,4,0.0],[920589,1,0.112283],[920590,2,-0.532231],[920591,4,0.0],[920592,1,-0.111836],[920593,2,-0.275278],[920594,4,0.0],[920595,4,0.0],[920596,3,-0.076254],[920597,3,-3.526565],[920598,4,0.0],[920599,1,-0.013166],[920600,2,2.890456],[920601,1,0.903195],[920602,1,-17.457107],[920603,2,-0.139469],[920604,2,-1.494059],[920605,2,-0.357658],[920606,3,0.09553],[920607,2,-0.665027],[920608,3,-0.291859],[920609,2,-4.138676],[920610,3,-2.664058],[920611,4,0.0],[920612,2,-1.855412],[920613,2,-0.214475],[920614,4,0.0],[920615,4,0.0],[920616,3,-0.004217],[920617,1,0.02658],[920618,2,0.092705],[920619,2,-0.027117],[920620,2,6.117586],[920621,3,-1.566997],[920622,3,-0.307339],[920623,2,-0.70091],[920624,3,-2.329326],[920625,1,0.263087],[920626,4,0.0],[920627,2,-0.139405],[920628,3,-0.085332],[920629,2,-1.159289],[920630,2,-0.282982],[920631,2,-0.128307],[920632,2,-0.080819],[920633,4,0.0],[920634,2,-0.216837],[920635,1,0.050677],[920636,4,0.0],[920637,1,1.022405],[920638,4,0.0],[920639,3,0.13756],[920640,3,-0.186056],[920641,2,-0.953452],[920642,1,1.386986],[920643,3,-0.600189],[920644,4,0.0],[920645,4,0.0],[920646,1,0.842062],[920647,4,0.0],[920648,3,2.600116],[920649,3,0.139856],[920650,1,0.118011],[920651,4,0.0],[920652,4,0.0],[920653,4,0.0],[920654,3,-0.118899],[920655,3,-0.068227],[920656,1,-0.006061],[920657,1,-0.009576],[920658,4,0.0],[920659,2,-0.580591],[920660,3,-0.767491],[920661,1,1.302937],[920662,4,0.0],[920663,3,-1.037473],[920664,4,0.0],[920665,2,5.377892],[920666,4,0.0],[920667,1,-0.038727],[920668,1,32.211268],[920669,2,-0.589978],[920670,3,1.653624],[920671,3,-0.230418],[920672,4,0.0],[920673,1,0.914497],[920674,4,0.0],[920675,3,-2.557433],[920676,3,-0.948221],[920677,3,-10.498425],[920678,2,-1.260269],[920679,1,0.333711],[920680,4,0.0],[920681,2,0.074902],[920682,4,0.0],[920683,2,-2.819022],[920684,4,0.0],[920685,2,-0.928273],[920686,4,0.0],[920687,2,0.05619],[920688,2,-7.834781],[920689,2,-0.865691],[920690,1,5.86973],[920691,2,1.470961],[920692,1,18.205424],[920693,2,-0.85926],[920694,2,-6.178339],[920695,2,-0.122392],[920696,2,0.472613],[920697,2,-0.57176],[920698,2,-1.277461],[920699,4,0.0],[920700,4,0.0],[920701,2,-1.447043],[920702,3,-2.250239],[920703,3,-0.026951],[920704,1,-1.808927],[920705,2,-4.75093],[920706,1,0.048683],[920707,3,0.020959],[920708,2,-0.915771],[920709,2,-2.17496],[920710,2,-0.206364],[920711,3,0.471123],[920712,3,4.439213],[920713,2,-1.130383],[920714,1,0.08192],[920715,2,-0.471371],[920716,2,-0.324941],[920717,3,0.755701],[920718,1,0.82119],[920719,2,-0.171597],[920720,1,-0.115111],[920721,3,0.440442],[920722,3,-0.200873],[920723,2,-0.415844],[920724,1,0.033142],[920725,1,1.186724],[920726,2,-2.413075],[920727,2,-5.185037],[920728,1,0.038423],[920729,4,0.0],[920730,4,0.0],[920731,4,0.0],[920732,4,0.0],[920733,4,0.0],[920734,1,6.234493],[920735,3,-0.155096],[920736,4,0.0],[920737,4,0.0],[920738,1,-0.215721],[920739,2,-4.137521],[920740,3,-0.196578],[920741,3,-0.209221],[920742,2,3.673028],[920743,4,0.0],[920744,4,0.0],[920745,1,-0.108739],[920746,2,1.128142],[920747,2,0.740349],[920748,2,-0.530213],[920749,2,-2.541651],[920750,3,-0.12913],[920751,3,0.825685],[920752,4,0.0],[920753,1,0.0],[920754,1,4.947875],[920755,4,0.0],[920756,3,0.660343],[920757,1,-0.021101],[920758,3,2.270182],[920759,3,-1.153822],[920760,1,0.903937],[920761,1,1.762155],[920762,1,4.497136],[920763,3,-0.202244],[920764,4,0.0],[920765,4,0.0],[920766,2,-0.240461],[920767,1,9.904483],[920768,4,0.0],[920769,2,1.500229],[920770,4,0.0],[920771,3,0.839697],[920772,4,0.0],[920773,3,-0.681419],[920774,3,-0.435373],[920775,1,-0.127343],[920776,1,15.127666],[920777,1,-1.180232],[920778,3,1.843229],[920779,2,-0.300976],[920780,1,-0.019557],[920781,3,-4.861712],[920782,3,-0.536322],[920783,4,0.0],[920784,4,0.0],[920785,3,-0.029056],[920786,4,0.0],[920787,2,-0.568661],[920788,1,5.079903],[920789,1,0.070862],[920790,4,0.0],[920791,3,-0.387738],[920792,1,-0.053933],[920793,2,-0.090824],[920794,4,0.0],[920795,3,-0.542936],[920796,4,0.0],[920797,2,-0.191581],[920798,2,-1.070341],[920799,3,-0.203993],[920800,1,0.793045],[920801,1,-0.283288],[920802,3,3.7477],[920803,1,0.44348],[920804,3,-0.113812],[920805,4,0.0],[920806,3,-0.737639],[920807,2,-1.838406],[920808,4,0.0],[920809,1,1.925267],[920810,2,-0.779154],[920811,1,3.268265],[920812,1,-0.091342],[920813,1,0.001667],[920814,2,-0.511447],[920815,3,-0.154523],[920816,3,-3.512225],[920817,2,0.007333],[920818,1,0.556502],[920819,2,0.035134],[920820,2,-0.141044],[920821,4,0.0],[920822,1,0.007803],[920823,2,-14.29408],[920824,2,0.836028],[920825,3,-0.314422],[920826,4,0.0],[920827,1,0.0],[920828,2,7.189614],[920829,4,0.0],[920830,2,-0.616055],[920831,2,0.059652],[920832,4,0.0],[920833,4,0.0],[920834,4,0.0],[920835,3,-2.072756],[920836,3,-1.641285],[920837,4,0.0],[920838,3,-0.90318],[920839,3,-0.230901],[920840,4,0.0],[920841,1,-2.025389],[920842,2,0.073908],[920843,2,-2.068913],[920844,2,-0.058277],[920845,4,0.0],[920846,3,1.161008],[920847,3,-0.146054],[920848,1,2.099053],[920849,4,0.0],[920850,3,-0.129864],[920851,2,-0.512838],[920852,1,0.041688],[920853,1,0.0],[920854,4,0.0],[920855,2,-2.738454],[920856,4,0.0],[920857,2,-0.335228],[920858,1,-0.236469],[920859,4,0.0],[920860,1,-8.844014],[920861,4,0.0],[920862,1,0.602891],[920863,4,0.0],[920864,1,0.005417],[920865,3,-2.609478],[920866,2,-0.628445],[920867,4,0.0],[920868,3,1.323317],[920869,4,0.0],[920870,1,0.11326],[920871,1,-0.011318],[920872,1,-0.013574],[920873,3,-2.048007],[920874,3,-0.227797],[920875,2,-2.426989],[920876,3,-1.736875],[920877,2,-1.386283],[920878,4,0.0],[920879,1,-5.887313],[920880,1,-2.190707],[920881,2,-0.185139],[920882,1,3.145971],[920883,1,0.900029],[920884,1,45.218345],[920885,3,-0.503562],[920886,1,-0.017442],[920887,3,-0.053861],[920888,2,-7.482651],[920889,1,0.444789],[920890,3,-0.027965],[920891,4,0.0],[920892,2,-0.181464],[920893,3,-0.0493],[920894,2,-1.389842],[920895,3,0.469756],[920896,4,0.0],[920897,2,-0.287709],[920898,3,1.358718],[920899,1,3.517912],[920900,3,-0.19713],[920901,3,-0.582968],[920902,3,0.370436],[920903,3,-1.019118],[920904,3,-0.362143],[920905,3,0.05691],[920906,4,0.0],[920907,2,-0.188827],[920908,1,-1.077479],[920909,2,-0.8175],[920910,2,-0.409742],[920911,4,0.0],[920912,1,5.267271],[920913,3,-0.245229],[920914,2,-1.047023],[920915,4,0.0],[920916,3,-0.33539],[920917,1,0.161806],[920918,2,-0.076542],[920919,3,0.353331],[920920,1,-3.632107],[920921,4,0.0],[920922,2,-0.743187],[920923,4,0.0],[920924,1,-0.085572],[920925,2,-1.627055],[920926,1,0.005179],[920927,3,-3.391141],[920928,1,0.020455],[920929,3,-0.957244],[920930,1,-0.000977],[920931,3,-0.720154],[920932,3,-0.087409],[920933,2,5.766068],[920934,3,-1.320341],[920935,2,-1.061201],[920936,2,-0.997473],[920937,4,0.0],[920938,3,-0.127795],[920939,1,-0.021678],[920940,2,1.694415],[920941,3,-4.787577],[920942,4,0.0],[920943,3,-0.472332],[920944,1,1.093846],[920945,2,-1.921811],[920946,3,-0.057556],[920947,2,0.512374],[920948,3,0.215334],[920949,4,0.0],[920950,2,0.274386],[920951,4,0.0],[920952,3,-1.492484],[920953,1,0.176149],[920954,2,-0.113336],[920955,2,3.714915],[920956,3,-0.888124],[920957,3,-1.165261],[920958,3,-0.026431],[920959,4,0.0],[920960,4,0.0],[920961,1,-0.019483],[920962,2,-0.114388],[920963,4,0.0],[920964,2,0.010688],[920965,2,0.052944],[920966,2,0.028203],[920967,4,0.0],[920968,2,-6.306879],[920969,2,0.447707],[920970,1,47.226557],[920971,4,0.0],[920972,2,5.596897],[920973,1,-2.033667],[920974,4,0.0],[920975,2,-0.647081],[920976,2,14.092576],[920977,4,0.0],[920978,3,-0.071216],[920979,3,-0.313032],[920980,2,-0.531586],[920981,3,-3.404015],[920982,2,-0.230326],[920983,1,-0.00612],[920984,3,-3.42794],[920985,4,0.0],[920986,3,0.887858],[920987,4,0.0],[920988,2,0.182791],[920989,1,0.0],[920990,4,0.0],[920991,3,-2.24849],[920992,4,0.0],[920993,2,-2.818832],[920994,4,0.0],[920995,1,-0.044894],[920996,3,-1.401747],[920997,1,-0.099182],[920998,3,0.152837],[920999,1,-2.158751]],"worst_seeds":[{"seed":920602,"s":1,"d":-17.457107089200008,"candidate_edge":79.1583059062,"comparator_edge":96.6154129954},{"seed":920823,"s":2,"d":-14.294079951999947,"candidate_edge":576.8770527785,"comparator_edge":591.1711327305},{"seed":920677,"s":3,"d":-10.498425019299997,"candidate_edge":29.9032551232,"comparator_edge":40.4016801425},{"seed":920860,"s":1,"d":-8.8440144616,"candidate_edge":1.0337104552,"comparator_edge":9.8777249168},{"seed":920688,"s":2,"d":-7.834780980299996,"candidate_edge":135.8128326656,"comparator_edge":143.6476136459},{"seed":920888,"s":2,"d":-7.482650970499998,"candidate_edge":8.7310231054,"comparator_edge":16.2136740759},{"seed":920968,"s":2,"d":-6.306878887200014,"candidate_edge":285.7440528221,"comparator_edge":292.0509317093},{"seed":920694,"s":2,"d":-6.178339121699992,"candidate_edge":419.8172484288,"comparator_edge":425.9955875505},{"seed":920879,"s":1,"d":-5.88731348200001,"candidate_edge":109.3268439993,"comparator_edge":115.2141574813},{"seed":920727,"s":2,"d":-5.185037459900059,"candidate_edge":613.4965351917,"comparator_edge":618.6815726516}],"off_target_zero":false,"notes":"Unmodified simulator b244530ee2a6247b5f930830eeca9dd950da0e7e; default config, 2000 steps; serial paired runs in 50-seed chunks. Differences and statistics use returned total_edge without additional rounding; only per_seed d is rounded to 6 decimals. SE uses sample standard deviation. No tuning or finalist seeds used. Timing is wall time of engine.run only; check runs excluded. Observed mean winners: 1:MA, 2:B_RC, 3:B_RC, 4:tie; spread 1 is P."}